Greek Tony`s Pizza & Sub Shop in Carmel

Great environment and Pizza! I have lived in Carmel for 20 years and this was my first visit. This will definitely be my go to pizza restaurant in the area. They have a love of hockey which I can appreciate. They even have an amazing hockey done foosball style game in the arcade area.

Amazing place! All the food is reasonably priced and this place has definitely stepped up into one of my top favorite pizza places. The breadsticks are easily my favorite from anywhere and the pizza is delicious. The dough has a great taste and texture and the cheese is quality. The restaurant is decorated with Hockey apparel (a nod to the owner's past career as a pro hockey player) and they have a very nice party room. The staff has always been friendly and welcoming. This will be a place we will be visiting frequently. Highly recommend!

One of my favorite places for lunch. Food and service are always fantastic! I also love how large the portions are for the price. Highly recommend!

Love their antipasta salad. Yum!

Slice was huge and delicious. Good beer selection too. Nice place, will be making this a regular lunch stop.

Food is really good here. Gyros and pizza are fantastic and I can't wait to try the Italian Beef sandwich on my next visit. Update: the Italian Beef Sandwich was really good. I got mine wet which just adds to the flavor.

Great bread sticks!!! And wow the Chicago Italian beef left me in awe. I am from Chicago area and the sandwich was top notch. Highly recommend!!!

Had the deluxe minus mushrooms and an order of breadsticks. Lemme tell you sumthin... excellent. Nothing really more to say. You will not be disappointed.

The Harris family has been making the best pizza and subs for 30 plus years Wonderful food made by a excellent staff who are very friendly. Order the thin crust pizza it’s the bomb !!!

Prices skyrocketed since my last visit maybe a year ago!

Always a friendly atmosphere. Good quantity and quality of food. Great for a quick lunch or group party.

Friendly staff.Great fresh salads with homemade croutons and salad dressings.The breadsticks were yummy!The pizza was delicious and made perfectly!We just found a new favorite pizza and sub place! :)

Fun local food stop with quality lunch options. It is not very fast so if you are in a hurry don't pick this place

The food is fantastic, they could better the way they handle orders, but the flavor makes up for the wait.

Great single slice of pizza. Delicious breadsticks. Only complaint is they dont have a pizza slice and breadsticks combo.

Classic Carmel pizza treasure! Best breadsticks in the area.

Good sandwiches, but I think they changed the way they make their steak sub.

A real local pizza joint with the best breadsticks ever made

Excellent local very popular lunch place. However I am sad to see their prices continue to rise. $11 for a sandwich and a drink is just a little bit too much for me to pay. Most people probably won't notice but I am on a fixed income and have to watch pennies now.

Great food but service can be slow

Wonderful little pizza joint. I love places like these that have that small-town feel. Great pizza with bread sticks. A little bit on the more greasy side. Only reason it's not 5 stars. Great Grub overall!! 😁

This is a hidden little gem. If you love toasty subs or good pizza, this is your place!

Great food and even better service. Better than any chain pizza.

Pizza was phenominal!!!! Breadsticks too!!!!!small shop,good food,good people.

Great place to visit and have a great lunch.Italian beef sandwich is outstanding.

Best pizza around. Older building but don't let that turn you off. Call it character & enjoy the best pizza, best antipasto & best bread stick around. All done up by friendly staff. Family owned businesses since day one. Awesome stuff.

Great sandwiches. Their veggie #6 is delicious!

Pizza wasn't cheap...but was tasty. Breadsticks are awesome. Wish they had a website that allowed online ordering.

Loved it, breadsticks, pizza and sandwich were all amazing

Classic small town pizzaria with large portions and great flavor!

The food smells incredibly good. I just like this restaurant

Omg Greek Tony's pizza was sooooo good! Even my picky teenager absolutely loved it! We were blowing off time while waiting for my daughter and grandaughter at riley's childrens hospital and googled local pizza shop's saw they had great reviews so we had to check it out and they most certainly stand up to their reputation! We got a hand tossed pizza and holy cow i was impressed how thick the crust was! I can't imagine what their deep dish is like! Most definitely gonna go back when we are in the area again!!

Great Pizza! Family friendly!! Large portions!!

Love, Love, Love this place!! Not the fanciest place in Carmel - just good Pizza - and the best bread sticks. the pizza crust is not too thick and not too thin - just right. I'm a huge fan of the Bacon Cheeseburger pizza - it has a nice blend of 7 cheeses, tomato slices and not spicy ground beef for toppings. The bread sticks come out piping hot with loads of butter and Parmesan cheese generously sprinkled over them. They are big, individual bread sticks that can fill you up - I keep to a limit of one, even though I want more! so I'll have room for the yummy pizza!!

Went here based on a recommendation. The lunch special was a killer deal. The salad was a little underwhelming (only lettuce and two tomatoes) but all was forgiven with the amazing bread sticks and pizza. Those were probably the most tasty bread sticks I've ever had here in central Indiana. The restaurant is old inside but has a great family feel to it and the staff is friendly. Food came out pretty quickly during lunch rush. I would definitely recommend for those who might have driven by but never stopped in like I had done for many years! Well worth it and I'll be back to try some other pizza options.

The food was fairly decent. I ordered the gyro platter, a salad, and mac n cheese. The salad and mac was delicious. The gyro was ok, it was over cooked and dry. The service left a lot to be desired. Random people walking behind the counter that were not employees didn't seem professional even for a pizza/sub shop. Not in a rush to return to a place that I once loved.

Tried this place for the first time and was pleasantly surprised. The gyro was Huge!! We also had pizza and bread sticks. The pizza is one of the better places I've had, but the bread sticks are what really stand out. They are amazing and a must order if you go here.

In town for business, my friend Brian from Harmeson Electric recommended you guys. Definitely did not disappoint! Thanks Tony’s and thanks Brian, Indy is treating me right!. :)

Flat out awesome!!!

Delicious gyro. They don't skimp on the meat. I recommend.

How can the most unassuming looking pizza place also have some of the best pizza in Indy? Go find out. You can thank me later.

Pizza is decent, came in for lunch and waited 20 mins for 1 slice a pepperoni pizza. It was not busy at all and other patrons were getting their food before me. You should have 2 go specials as well.

Great lunch specials. You will not walk away hungry.

Great food and service. It was cold and drafty inside with ceiling fans blowing down (in December) that was made worse every time people went in or out of front door

Good pizza, great value.

Do not recommend at all.

I remember going to this place, 20 years ago when I worked at an Osco in the area. Now we live in the area and this is our favorite local pizza places! Great bread sticks and awesome pizza—not a lot of sauce, good amount of cheese and other toppings are also plentiful. Sandwiches are also great. Never had dine in, but carry out is always easy and staff is friendly and personable. Give it a try, I don't think you'll be disappointed!

Great pie. First time here. I will return for sure!

Mama's sub is delicious! It has that homely family ran business feel to it that you can't seem to get anymore. We go about once a month.

Services wonderful slices of pizza are big breadsticks are big the place is just great